Bestsellers

These are the most-loved items at Keys—picked by hundreds of shoppers. If you’re new here or shopping a quick gift, start below and you’ll be happy with what you grab.

The Green Witch Tarot by Ann Moura, Kiri Àstergaard Leonard

$ 31.99

Pinheads Three Witches

$ 29.95

Witches Brew Mug & Spoon

$ 16.95

Witches Brew Coasters

$ 20.95

Witch's Brew Large Cauldron Mug

$ 20.95

Witch's Potion Cauldron Mug

$ 22.95

Pinheads The Octopus Witch

$ 14.95

Witches Brew Tea for One Set

$ 48.95

Flying Witch Beads

$ 55.00

Witch's Wreath Embroidered Hanging

$ 45.00

Teen Witch by Silver Ravenwolf

$ 19.99

The Witch's Book of Shadows by Jason Mankey

$ 15.99

Scottish Witchcraft & Magick by Raymond Buckland

$ 16.99

WitchCraft Cocktails by Julia Halina Hadas

$ 16.99

The Ultimate Guide to Witchcraft by Anjou Kiernan

$ 26.99

Grimoire for the Green Witch by Ann Moura

$ 24.99

The Living Temple of Witchcraft Volume Two by Christopher Penczak

$ 27.99

The Witches' Goddess by Janet & Stewart Farrar

$ 26.95

Yellow Crackle Witch Hat Earrings (ER75)

$ 15.00

"Witch's Coffee House" Apron

$ 75.00

"Witches' Brew" Apron

$ 75.00