Skip to Content
  1. Products
  2. Bestsellers

Bestsellers

These are the most-loved items at Keys—picked by hundreds of shoppers. If you’re new here or shopping a quick gift, start below and you’ll be happy with what you grab.
Sort By Sort By: Featured
[1713034803] Millennial Gaia statue 24"

Millennial Gaia statue 24"

$ 224.95
[176549115431] Fierce Hecate Statue

Fierce Hecate Statue

$ 40.95
[176549115677] Sorcerer's Staff

Sorcerer's Staff

$ 61.95
[1713030403] Millennial Gaia statue 4"

Millennial Gaia statue 4"

$ 25.95
[11112] Shark Teeth (broken)

Shark Teeth (broken)

$ 0.25
[176549118937] Maiden Mother Crone Backflow Incense Burner

Maiden Mother Crone Backflow Incense Burner

$ 49.95
[1713030606] Cernunnos

Cernunnos

$ 22.95
[176549117169] Maiden Mother Crone Gazing Ball

Maiden Mother Crone Gazing Ball

$ 49.95
[12184] KTM Haunt & Hearth Incense

KTM Haunt & Hearth Incense

$ 9.95
[1326742168] Llewellyn's Sabbat Essentials: Samhain

Llewellyn's Sabbat Essentials: Samhain

$ 12.99
[1326187199] Halloween! by Silver Ravenwolf

Halloween! by Silver Ravenwolf

$ 17.99
[1326758213] Llewellyn's Little Book of Halloween by Mickie Mueller

Llewellyn's Little Book of Halloween by Mickie Mueller

$ 14.99
[171313373099] Dead Thirsty Coaster Set

Dead Thirsty Coaster Set

$ 24.95
[1326762487] Llewellyn's Little Book of The Day of the Dead by Jaime Gironés

Llewellyn's Little Book of The Day of the Dead by Jaime Gironés

$ 13.99
[6726706080] Do Dead People Walk Their Dogs? by Concetta Bertoldi

Do Dead People Walk Their Dogs? by Concetta Bertoldi

$ 16.99
[6025] Death's Head Moth Card Stand

Death's Head Moth Card Stand

$ 35.00
[6926345928] A Witches' Bible by Janet and Stewart Farrar

A Witches' Bible by Janet and Stewart Farrar

$ 28.95
[2626432358] Aradia: Gospel of the Witches by Charles Leland

Aradia: Gospel of the Witches by Charles Leland

$ 16.95
[1326765433] A Witch's Guide to Wildcraft by JD Walker

A Witch's Guide to Wildcraft by JD Walker

$ 17.99
[11320] Aries Witch by Dominguez et al.

Aries Witch by Dominguez et al.

$ 16.99
[12188] Introduction to Witchcraft by Sara L. Mastros

Introduction to Witchcraft by Sara L. Mastros

$ 28.95